Statistics

Auto Repair Estimate Statistics: Costs, Labor, Parts, and EV Trends

Key U.S. auto repair estimate statistics covering repair costs, labor, parts, diagnostics, vehicle type, and common check-engine repairs.

Auto repair estimates are being shaped by higher labor costs, more parts per repair, and increasing diagnostic requirements. CCC reported an average total cost of repair (TCOR) of $4,667 in the third quarter of 2024, compared with $4,501 in the third quarter of 2023. That was a 3.7% year-over-year increase. The figures below separate collision-repair estimates, mechanical repairs, roadside events, and workforce data so each statistic keeps its proper context.

Contents

Overall repair estimate costs

CCC’s Q3 2024 TCOR of $4,667 is a collision-repair measure, not a typical price for every maintenance visit or mechanical repair. It rose from $4,501 in Q3 2023. In its Q1 2025 Crash Course, CCC said 2024 TCOR was likely to finish 3% to 4% higher than in 2023, describing that as the lowest annual increase since 2017. This is a forecast stated by CCC at that time, rather than a final independently verified result.

CCC also tracked how the dollar contribution to TCOR changed against 2020. The average dollar change in TCOR contribution rose from $395 in 2021 to $1,285 in 2024. CCC said parts had contributed at least 50% of the increase versus 2020, while labor and miscellaneous costs were the largest contributors to the increase in repair cost over that same baseline. These comparisons use 2020 as the reference point and should not be read as a single shop’s estimate for an individual vehicle.

For a different repair category, Cars.com reported that CarMD’s 2025 Vehicle Health Index used more than 31 million failures on vehicles needing repairs in 2024. The average check-engine-related repair cost was $415.31 in 2024, down from $427.56 in 2023. Cars.com reported that parts costs fell 5% from 2023, while labor costs rose 1.4%.

The difference between $4,667 in collision TCOR and $415.31 for the average check-engine-related repair illustrates why an estimate needs a clearly defined repair category. A collision estimate can contain body work, refinishing, parts, labor, scanning, and calibration. A check-engine repair may involve one of several components and is measured differently.

Parts, labor, and repair complexity

CCC reported average price per part increased 0.2% in 2023, after increases of 7.3% and 5.4% in the prior two years. Through Q3 2024, the average price per part was up 1.4% year over year. CCC reported quarterly increases of 2.0% in Q2 2024 and 1.2% in Q3 2024.

The number of parts on an estimate also changed. CCC reported average parts-per-appraisal of 11.2 in 2020, 12.2 in 2021, 13.2 in 2022, and 13.7 in 2023. Its year-to-date 2024 average parts-per-repair was 13.4. In its Q1 2025 report, CCC gave a full-year 2024 part-utilization figure of 13.5 parts per repair estimate. The two 2024 figures come from different reporting descriptions and periods, so they should not be treated as contradictory replacements for one another.

Labor measures moved as well. CCC reported 27.6 average labor hours per appraisal in 2023 and 27.3 hours through Q3 2024. For the full year, CCC reported 27.3 average labor hours in 2024. Labor rates rose 7.5% in 2023 and 4.7% year over year through Q3 2024; CCC later reported a 4.5% increase for full-year 2024.

CCC also reported that vehicles went into shops for repairs nine days sooner in Q3 2024 than in Q3 2023, while average repair time fell by 1.4 days per repair. Scheduling pressure nevertheless varied over time. Crash Network’s U.S. national collision-repair scheduling backlog was 2.1 weeks in Q4 2024, compared with 4.0 weeks in Q1 2024 and a peak of 5.8 weeks in Q1 2023, according to the CCC Crash Course Q4 2024 and Crash Network.

Estimates by vehicle powertrain

Vehicle technology affects both claim mix and estimate complexity. CCC reported that EVs represented 1.1% of vehicles in operation, or about 3.3 million vehicles, and 2.5% of all repairable claims through Q3 2024. EV repairable claim volume was up 27% year over year.

For vehicles three years old or newer, CCC reported the following change in claim mix:

Vehicle typeEarlier shareLater shareContext
ICE95%80%Claims for vehicles three years old or newer
Hybrid3.7%13.2%Claims for vehicles three years old or newer
EV1.4%6.8%Claims for vehicles three years old or newer

CCC also reported that 79.4% of repairable EV estimates were for vehicles three years old or newer. The corresponding shares were 60.3% for hybrids and 26.3% for ICE vehicles. For ICE vehicles, 47.4% of repairable estimates were for vehicles seven years old or older.

Cycle time differed by powertrain in CCC’s 2024 figures. The average time between the last estimate and vehicle out was 37.6 days for EVs, 30.9 days for hybrids, and 32.3 days for combustion vehicles. These are estimate-to-release cycle-time measures, not a promise that every repair will take those amounts of time.

Mitchell reported that U.S. repairable BEV claims were 2.4% in the first half of 2024 and that BEV repair cost was 46.9% higher than non-EV repair cost in its Plugged-In coverage. In Mitchell’s 2024-in-review figures, U.S. repairable BEV claim severity fell from $6,707 in 2024 to $6,395 in 2025. ICE severity fell from $5,176 to $5,105, PHEV severity fell from $5,759 to $5,628, and MHEV severity rose from $4,865 to $5,054.

Mitchell’s Canadian figures provide a separate geography. Canadian BEV severity fell from $7,410 to $7,253, ICE severity fell from $5,726 to $5,659, MHEV severity fell from $6,268 to $6,267, and PHEV severity rose from $6,411 to $6,442. In 2025, Canadian repairable BEV claims were 4.77%, up 24% year over year; MHEV claims were 4.44%, up 29%; and PHEV claims were 1.55%, up 26%.

Scans, calibrations, and supplements

Modern repair estimates can include diagnostic operations in addition to visible replacement or refinishing work. CCC reported that 85% of direct-repair-program (DRP) appraisals included a scan in 2024, while calibrations were trending toward 30% of DRP appraisals. For repairable DRP appraisals, CCC reported that 86.3% included a scan and 29.9% included a calibration.

The timing of those operations matters when comparing an initial estimate with later supplements. CCC reported that 91.7% of scans appeared on the initial estimate, identified as E01. By contrast, 56.3% of calibrations appeared on a supplement. A supplement can therefore change the apparent scope of an estimate after the first inspection.

Mitchell reported an average of 1.70 calibrations per estimate for BEVs in 2024, compared with 1.54 for ICE vehicles and 1.63 for hybrids. The measures describe average calibration frequency per estimate; they are not dollar prices and do not establish what a particular vehicle requires.

Common check-engine repair costs

The CarMD figures reported by Cars.com show how widely mechanical repair prices can vary within the check-engine category. The 2024 average costs were:

RepairAverage cost
Catalytic-converter replacement$1,348
Ignition-coil-and-spark-plug replacement$400
Mass-air-flow-sensor replacement$323
Oxygen-sensor replacement$254
EVAP canister purge control valve replacement$144

AAA separately estimated that catalytic-converter replacement can cost between $1,000 and $4,000. AAA estimated fuel-pump replacement at $1,150 to $1,400 and a mid-range paint job at $1,000 to $4,500. These are ranges or estimates from AAA, while the CarMD values reported by Cars.com are average costs for 2024. Neither source makes these figures a guaranteed quote for a specific make, model, location, or repair condition.

Shop pricing, guarantees, and roadside demand

AAA cited a 2025 PartsTech analysis reporting that almost half of repair shops price labor between $120 and $159 per hour. AAA also said members save a minimum of 10% on repair labor at Approved Auto Repair facilities, subject to a $75 limit in some areas. At those facilities, AAA said the final bill cannot exceed the written estimate by more than 10% without prior approval. AAA said repairs are guaranteed for 24 months or 24,000 miles, and members can use more than 7,000 shops in its network.

Roadside demand offers another view of vehicle problems, although a roadside event is not the same as a repair estimate. AAA said it received over 27 million emergency roadside calls in 2024. About 13 million were for towing, about 7 million were for battery issues, and EV service calls totaled about 215,000, or 0.8% of total roadside events.

Automotive repair work and wages

BLS reported a median annual wage of $49,670 for automotive service technicians and mechanics in May 2024. The lowest 10% earned less than $33,660, while the highest 10% earned more than $80,850. BLS reported a May 2024 median annual wage of $51,680 for automotive body and related repairers and $47,260 for automotive glass installers and repairers.

BLS projected automotive body and glass repairer employment to grow 2% from 2024 to 2034, with about 16,000 openings per year over the decade. Separately, BLS reported average hourly earnings of $27.46 for automotive repair and maintenance in April 2026. The wage figures describe workers or industry earnings; they are not the same as a customer-facing shop labor rate.

Written by

hpautowerks.com Editorial Team

Editorial team

hpautowerks.com publishes practical how-to guides and educational articles with clear steps and useful context.